Common mistakes when implementing a cookie banner

Author:

  • Klaudia Gajkowska
    Klaudia Gajkowska

Table of contents

Enjoyed this article?
Share with your friends

A cookie banner is often the first thing visitors see. It needs to explain what the site does and let people control optional cookies.

Start with the first article in this series: Is your website’s use of cookies compliant?

Once you know what the banner should say, check whether the site actually follows the choices people make.

Test what happens behind the banner

A banner can look right and still fail to manage consent.

A regulator or platform reviewing your site can check how the banner and the site behave, including whether visitors can easily change their minds and withdraw consent.

 

Before signing off the banner, check for these common mistakes.

Misunderstanding the rules on cookies

It’s easy to confuse GDPR rules on personal data with the separate rules on storing and accessing information on a device.


Start with these distinctions:

Assuming consent from continued browsing

Some websites still use notices that say “By visiting this website, you agree to our use of cookies.”

That message tells visitors that cookies are used but gives them no genuine choice.

If the site uses only strictly necessary cookies, it may only need to explain what they do. A notice alone won’t authorise optional tracking, such as advertising tags that run before visitors choose.


If visitors have to accept optional cookies simply to keep browsing, check whether the consent can be considered freely given. 

Loading optional cookies before consent

A banner can appear to offer all the right choices even when the tracking behind it is configured incorrectly.

For example, a closer look might show that dozens of cookies were already set before the visitor selected an option.

Where prior consent is required, block optional cookies and tags until the visitor agrees to the relevant purpose. 

Ask your developer or a consent specialist to test which cookies and tags load before and after each choice.

Bundling all optional cookies into one choice

A banner may look clear because it offers an accept and a reject button.


The problem arises when visitors who want to accept some optional uses have no way to choose between them.

Consent must be specific. A consent banner should give people a meaningful choice by purpose, so they know what kinds of tracking they’re allowing.

For example, you can group cookies by purpose:

If you offer “Accept all”, also make it easy to reject optional cookies and manage preferences by purpose.

Making consent hard to change or withdraw

The banner may work on a first visit and block optional cookies until the user agrees. The problem comes later if the site offers no way to change the selection or withdraw consent altogether.

The GDPR requires withdrawal to be as easy as giving consent. Visitors should have an accessible way to do it on the site without having to clear cookies in their browser. 

Keeping no record of consent

Where you rely on consent, keep evidence of when and how it was obtained. Document how tracking handles personal data, including which third-party services are involved and where the data goes.

How can you avoid these mistakes?

If you need help with the setup, consider a consent management tool such as Cookiebot. It can provide a banner and help keep records of visitors’ choices.

Cookiebot can handle the consent interface. Test the setup and review it when your tags or website change. 


Check the site before signing off the banner. If you’re unsure how its tags respond to consent, ask a developer experienced in consent management to review the setup.

Need help with your cookie banner?

We’ve configured consent tools for many sites. Get in touch and we’ll check how your banner and tracking work together.
A properly configured banner can reduce the risk of non-compliance and make it clearer to visitors how their choices are handled.

We offer a one-off service to set up or fix cookie consent on your site.

Want to learn more?

Read the full guide for more detail, or download our free e-book for a step-by-step explanation.

Authors

  • Klaudia Gajkowska
    Klaudia Gajkowska

Get in touch and tell us how we can help.

Join the businesses that trust us with their projects.